Beatty: Third-party groups are ‘new face of the Klan’
Spartanburg Herald-Journal
By Bob Dalton
6/5/08
State Supreme Court Justice Don Beatty said Wednesday that third-party groups using him as the “poster boy” to attack candidates across South Carolina are the “new face of the Klan.”
Beatty accused organizations such as the S.C. Club for Growth, South Carolinians for Responsible Government and Conservatives in Action of distorting his record as a legislator in the 1990s to scare voters away from candidates they oppose. He said they’ve never cited any of the decisions he’s handed down in more than 12 years on the bench that would support their claims that he’s a liberal judge.
“It makes me wonder what their real reason is for attacking me,” Beatty said. “It’s because I’m an easy target, and they can use code words and my black face to appeal to voters that they might be able to enrage against legislators that supported me…These people give conservatives a bad name. I’ve heard them referred to on more than one occasion as the new face of the (Ku Klux) Klan. I’m almost about to believe that.”
Reaction from representatives of the groups ranged from outrage to surprise.
SCRG spokesman Neil Mellen said Beatty’s comment was “insulting” and “incredibly offensive.” He said SCRG has looked at Beatty’s decisions, but the “most telling indicators” of his judicial approach could be found in his approach to legislation.
Club for Growth spokesman Matt Moore said he was “appalled that someone of Justice Beatty’s stature would evoke such strong language.” He pointed out that the group endorsed Tim Scott, an African-American running for the District 117 House seat.
“Club for Growth has been at the forefront of government restructuring issues,” Moore said. “Certainly movement in the right direction would allow more African-Americans, and any other race, to have more influence in state government.”
Conservatives in Action spokesman Taft Matney said he’d been called a lot of things, but a Klansman was never one of them.
“I’m ashamed Justice Beatty is representing our state on that court after making those assertions,” Matney said. “It’s absurd, it’s abhorrent and it’s a shame.”
Matney said Beatty was neglecting his duty to uphold the rights of others to express their opinions.
“For him to take issue with South Carolinians that disagree with him and attack their rights to share their opinions is abhorrent,” he said.
Beatty said that works both ways, and that he’s allowed to express his opinions as well. He said he wasn’t attacking anyone’s rights, but he was no longer going to sit silently while his reputation was maligned.
“I’ve been quiet on this issue for quite some time,” Beatty said. “Throughout the campaign (for the Supreme Court) I allowed it to go on. But since then it’s come up time and time again, and they’re using the same arguments they used before, knowing they aren’t true.”
Beatty said a mail piece that Conservatives in Action sent out opposing Rep. Bob Walker, R-Landrum, was Exhibit A.
The flier asks voters to call Walker and “tell him to stop supporting liberals for South Carolina state judgeships.” The flier lists 12 House bills, some dating back to 1992, as evidence that Beatty “voted with the pro-abortion radicals, voted against gun owners and pushed for higher taxes and more wasteful spending” - the same charges Conservatives in Action leveled a year ago in opposing Beatty’s election to the Supreme Court.
Beatty, armed with copies of the bills, gave a point-by-point rebuttal of those claims.
For example, the Conservatives in Action piece claims that bill 4720, filed in 1992, demonstrates Beatty’s willingness to raise taxes. The bill, however, relates to the Berkeley County Board of Education, “so as to provide that vacancies must be filled for the unexpired portion of the term by special election.”
Matney said he didn’t have the bill numbers in front of him so he couldn’t address Beatty’s assertions, but questioned whether some numbers could have been transposed on the flier.
Walker said the groups have attacked Beatty based on a variety of obscure amendments in some of those bills. But he, too, questioned whether race was the issue based on conversations with constituents.
Walker said a several voters told him that in a push-poll conducted in April, they were asked how they would rate him if they knew he had voted for a black judge. He said he didn’t know who paid for the calls, and that the callers did not identify themselves.
“I don’t know who put it out there,” Walker said. “But they couldn’t attack him on his record so they had to attack him on race.”
Rep. Bill Cotty, R-Columbia, said he understands why Beatty would feel the way he does. Cotty was targeted when he ran for re-election in 2006. He is now head of the group South Carolinians for Truth - which bills itself as a “watchdog group working to set the record straight when organizations misrepresent the truth.”
“They represent the worst in politics,” Cotty said. “If we don’t take steps to get rid of these groups … then we deserve the reputation that we’re getting for malicious, scandalous and low-level politics.”
Staff writer Jason Spencer contributed to this report.
A Note from Whitney
Dear Friends,
I can’t believe it’s been two years since my sisters and I first wrote asking you to vote for our Dad, Keith Kelly. At that time I attended the University of South Carolina and worked part-time at the State House for Representative Scott Talley. When Dad was elected, he joined me at the State House and it was awesome watching him at work. I was very proud of how hard he worked for Spartanburg County and I know you are too.
SHJ Interview
Spartanburg and Woodruff on list of top U.S. high schools
Spartanburg Herald-Journal
By Lee Gray
5/22/08
Two Spartanburg County high schools have been recognized on the 2008 Newsweek magazine / Washington Post list of top U.S. high schools. Both Spartanburg High School and Woodruff High School made the Challenge Index, which aims to measure how students perform given the rigor of the courses.
The formula counts the total number of AP tests taken at a school divided by the number of graduating seniors. Schools with a ratio of 1.000 or higher are placed on the list. This year that includes 1,358 schools, or about 5 percent of public high schools nationwide.
The article in the May 26 issue of Newsweek reads, “We are all seeking the same thing, which is schools that better serve our children and our nation by encouraging students to tackle tough subjects under the guidance of gifted teachers.”
This year is the fifth time since 2003 both WHS (ranked 763) and SHS (ranked 921) have been included on the Challenge Index.
“We pride ourselves on providing for all students,” said SHS principal Rodney Graves. “Anything we offer here we try to do it first class and try to be a leader in the state and a leader in the nation.”
The District 7 school offers 22 different AP courses to its students. Graves said the Index proves the commitment of the school, district and community to offer only the best to SHS students.
“We have a little bit of everything, and our school district has been very committed to having offerings. If students want to take it, we try to offer it,” he said.
Woodruff High School principal Karen Neal said she is thrilled the school is once again included among the nation’s top high schools. She said the ranking is an affirmation of the school’s offering of AP courses to students.
“We can see the results of our high expectations as our students are able to move on to college and are successful,” Neal said. “I think the AP program takes a large part of the credit there.”
Nineteen South Carolina public high schools made the list, up four since last year.
The list does not include schools with an average SAT score of more than 1300 or an ACT score of 29 or higher as it is only intended to recognize schools that challenge average students.
However, rankings of non-eligible schools and a complete list of schools on the Challenge Index can be found on Newsweek’s Web site at newsweek.com.
The Governor’s Citizenship Award
Every year, the Governor’s Citizenship Award program honors one student from each participating school for outstanding service, leadership, responsibility, character, and discipline.
This year, I was extremely proud to see my daughter, Hannah, win this year’s award for Woodruff High School. I also want to congratulate Patrick Tate Roebuck for winning the Governor’s Citizenship Award for Dorman High School.
Read more
Hannah Heads to the Prom
As you know, for the last couple years we have posted prom pictures. With Whitney and Lillie in college, Hannah will be the last one to leave home. Here are a couple shots:
Read more
What’s the real agenda? Group raises questions with fliers
Spartanburg Herald-Journal
By Jason Spencer
5/15/08
Hundreds of fliers are appearing in Spartanburg mailboxes supporting a specific slate of candidates, billing them as tax-cutting conservatives. But some say that the spending issues highlighted on those fliers are a veil to cover the group’s real agenda, school choice.
South Carolinians for Responsible Government has sent mailings in support of Republican candidates Roger Nutt, an engineer facing incumbent Rep. Keith Kelly, and Joey Millwood, a journalist facing incumbent Rep. Bob Walker in June. The group has also sent out a flier supporting Ken Roach, who is running against fellow Republican and retired gas company executive Mike Forrester to challenge Democrat Ronnie Hart in November.
Read more
Light barbs on cue at GOP debate
Spartanburg Herlad-Journal
By Jason Spencer
5/13/08
Like the sauce, the various candidates to take the stage Monday night at Ron’s Hog Pen BBQ were mostly different shades of red - and some of them had a little kick.
Sixteen state and local Republican candidates sat shoulder to shoulder on a tiny stage for nearly three hours in exchange for, at the most, about five minutes of scattered speaking time in a wide-ranging debate sponsored by the local GOP. Another arrived late, and opted to stand on the stage steps rather than shoehorn himself into the group.
Read more
GOP gathering for debate after BBQ
21 candidates invited to discuss issues important to campaigns
Spartanburg Herald Journal
By Jason Spencer
5/11/08
A boatload of Republican state and local candidates will sit down to eat pork Monday night before they spend two hours talking about cutting it, among other things.
Twenty-one candidates have been invited to a forum hosted by the Spartanburg County Republican Party. The debate begins at 7 p.m. at Ron’s Family Restaurant. The event will feature questions by Herald-Journal Editorial Page Editor Mike Smith, Hometown News reporter Leon Russ and WORD radio personality Bob McLain.
The panel also can opt to ask questions submitted beforehand by the audience.
“What I’m trying to accomplish is to let the general public come and see all the candidates for all the local contested primary races at one time,” county GOP Chairman Rick Beltram said.
“It helps when you can compare a House race in one area with a House race in a nearby area. I think everybody realizes that nobody can go down to Columbia and say, ‘I’m going to hold down spending.’ You can’t do it by yourself. It has to be a group of people … forming a working majority to get things passed.”
Read more
Immigration, the Budget, and Special Interest Groups
